Making manager effectiveness part of everyday efforts

No manager is flawless, but problems surface when inconsistent management quality affects the employee experience. According to a survey conducted by Gallup, employees working under poor management systems report being 60% more stressed than those working under strong management practices.*

This tension tends to show up at the worst possible time. When the company is small, it’s easier to absorb inconsistent management. As the organization grows, managers are forced to become more independent. Senior leadership can’t hold everyone’s hand, and HR can’t be in the room for every difficult conversation.

As breaking points pile up, HR often turns to strategy first. In many cases, however, the most well-honed people strategies and comprehensive training can’t fix management that falls short of expectations. It’s not the plan that’s lacking, but the execution.

This guide explains how HR leaders can close the gap between theory and practical manager support. You’ll learn how to embed best practices in managers’ daily reality, and how to measure manager effectiveness so you can continuously refine your approach.

* Gallup, 2023

Why effective management matters for everyone

“An ineffective manager doesn’t take time to understand their people or build trust. The best ones care deeply, they know where you want to grow, challenge you when needed, and make space for honest feedback.”

— Luck Dookchitra, former VP of People and Culture at Leapsome

Being a good boss is about more than just achieving quarterly targets and SMART goals. (After all, managers who create high-conflict situations that tank employee retention can still hit performance targets.) Effective managers use leadership skills to motivate, engage, and develop employees while creating an environment that helps every team member consistently do their best.

Building a consistent, effective managerial team can make an outsized impact on organizational outcomes. According to Gallup, individual manager effectiveness accounts for 70% of team engagement variance. So, team strength starts with the quality of a team’s management.

How to evaluate management success: Key metrics

“Engagement scores and trust metrics are signals, not goals. If a metric isn’t influencing business results, drop it and focus on what does.”

— Melanie Naranjo, Chief People Officer at Ethena

Measuring management effectiveness is a means to an end, not a goal in itself. These metrics should help HR identify when to intervene and provide proactive coaching and support as early as possible. They’re also useful for determining what new processes are working so you know what to replicate and what to recalibrate.

Here are a few of the most useful indicators of effective management in an organization.

Internal promotion rate

Most employees want to advance in their careers — so much so that they stay 41% longer at companies with high internal promotion rates. A manager’s promotion rate reflects how well they’re empowering team members to become future leaders, and whether that investment is creating a stronger talent pipeline overall.

You can calculate an internal promotion rate by dividing the number of promotions in a given period by the total number of team members under each manager:

promotion rate = number of promotions / total number of team members x 100%

If a manager’s promotion rate is below the organizational average, an investigation might be in order. A low rate can signal issues like a toxic environment or falling engagement.

High performer turnover rate

When strong talent starts jumping ship, there may be a problem with the employee experience or limited room for advancement. A spike in turnover on a specific team points toward managerial ineffectiveness more than broader organizational issues. Look at their managers’ performance alongside exit interviews: According to research from 15Five, more than half of employees cite unsupportive management as a major reason for leaving.

To track this manager effectiveness metric, start by identifying your top employees based on performance ratings, then check how often they leave over a specific period. Break the numbers down by individual managers so you can compare across teams, and judge this figure against the total turnover rate to see if high performers are leaving more frequently than average, too.

360-degree feedback scores

“If you can agree with your manager on a framework for what you discuss in your one on one, it stops feeling like micromanagement and starts feeling like shared ownership.”

— Liliya Apostolova, former VP of Marketing at Leapsome

360-degree performance reviews include the perspectives of peers and direct reports instead of just an employee’s immediate manager. Giving direct reports a chance to weigh in with upward feedback for their managers’ performance can reveal insights unlikely to be on the radar of managers’ own higher-ups, like their emotional intelligence and the specificity of the constructive feedback they give.

To conduct a 360-degree feedback session, gather anonymized reviews from the manager’s direct reports and peers from other teams. Compare their self-assessment against each reviewer’s ratings, and analyze the differences to surface gaps.

Discrepancies between a manager’s self-evaluations and how team members view them can signal unaddressed blind spots in their leadership. However, using 360-degree feedback as a way to eliminate underperforming managers can foster mistrust, because it can encourage unnecessary competition and unease about who might be next. Use these reviews as a way to personalize coaching and mentorship plans instead.

Running 360-degree performance reviews is a lot easier when you have the right tools. Modern HRIS platforms can collect and anonymize evaluations, then put this feedback in conversation with other pieces of performance data. Leapsome goes a step further and also collects engagement signals, then puts all the information about each employee in one place. By keeping day-to-day workflows and historical data in one system, you’ll have all the details you need to keep manager effectiveness high.

‍

📝 Smooth the way for regular engagement checks
‍
Leapsome’s Engagement Surveys helps HR teams quickly design and conduct surveys, then convert insights into actionable strategies.

👉 Explore Engagement Surveys

‍

What embedding manager effectiveness actually looks like

Even with a rock-solid process and the best intentions, HR’s attempts to build better managers won’t necessarily stick unless those designs become actionable, accessible processes. When systems languish in documents and spreadsheets, HR leaders have no way of knowing if managers are actually following the framework, and managers face an uphill battle in reliably applying the rules.

A connected HRIS embeds best practices into the same software managers already use. Building your people processes directly into managers’ daily workflows and tooling can create predictable behavior at scale instead of making managers rely solely on self-discipline and memory in hectic environments.

Here are some core principles to guide your HR team’s journey toward embedded manager effectiveness.

Managers need zero-friction access to people processes

Effective management practices happen more reliably when there are only a few steps to follow. When prompts show up inside a manager’s regular workflow, they’re more likely to see and act on the reminder. For instance, if a manager is onboarding a new direct report, removing potential blocks means they’ll have more time to prepare roadmaps, check in frequently, and streamline development conversations. 

Automated nudges are reminders managers can’t give themselves

Things slip through the cracks under pressure, even for the most talented managers. Automated nudges ensure the right behaviors happen at the right times, so managers don’t have to rely solely on their own memory.

For example, regular 1:1s make good management visible and measurable by documenting the conversations a manager leads — but only if the manager remembers to conduct them. Automated reminders mean check-ins are more likely to happen right on schedule.

‍

👥 Conduct 1:1s without tab-hopping

Leapsome provides the framework for custom or template-based 1:1s and helps HR teams track progress to guide managers toward the best next steps.

👉 Explore 1:1s & Team Meetings

‍

Good decisions come from the bigger picture

Managers make the best calls when they have the full context behind an issue. Embedding contextual decision-making means drawing goal-setting, engagement signals, and feedback into a single view. By replacing endless toggling between disconnected tools with a centralized dashboard, managers are more likely to have all the details they need to make the right choice for each decision.

How to improve manager effectiveness: Best practices

“Providing managers with more training or more skills does not increase their effectiveness. Instead, organizations must focus on job manageability — making the manager job more manageable is five times more effective than skills proficiency in improving manager effectiveness.”

— Mark Whittle, Vice President of Advisory at Gartner HR

One-off HR interventions rarely affect how managers lead months later. Learning how to be a good manager requires making people processes part of day-to-day workflows. These tips will help your HR team make it happen:

• Build development plans before problems show up: Treat coaching and leadership development as ongoing investments rather than crisis responses. Managers who don’t crack under pressure typically have active support to draw on well before difficult moments arise.

• Use technology to reduce friction, not just add features: Your choice of technology can make or break process application consistency. Look for platforms that make it easy to embed processes into your current systems instead of chasing the one with the longest list of features that forces a complete overhaul.

• Treat succession planning as continuous: Keeping tabs on future leaders avoids hasty decisions when a spot opens on the managerial team. Only looking for good candidates during annual review cycles is usually too slow — the strongest candidates may have left by the time review season comes around.

Make effective management an operational reality with Leapsome

Small and mid-sized organizations typically drop the ball on managerial effectiveness not because of bad strategy, but because they struggle to align good people processes with managers’ day-to-day workflows.

Leapsome helps HR leaders close the loop by turning consistent manager effectiveness into a system rather than an individual task. By combining structured 1:1s and continuous feedback with goal tracking and engagement visibility in a single unified HRIS and people management platform, prompts and processes become part of managers’ daily practice.

Predictable management behavior is a natural byproduct of the overall system. Leapsome puts managers and employees first and foremost, creating a smooth onramp to adoption that helps people processes stick across teams. Whether you’re managing five teams or 50, Leapsome helps great management become the rule, not the exception.

“A big part of our people work happens through Leapsome — we have many manager touch points there, such as pulse surveys where managers gain a good overview over their team’s mood and health.We also have a yearly talent assessment cycle, with performance reviews and career development conversations tracked through Leapsome. Managers prepare these meetings through the Meetings function, set up developmental goals, and track them over the quarter. Additionally, we track company goals through Leapsome.” — Eva Gallee, Senior People Business Partner at ProGlove

‍

🧰 Replace a patchwork of platforms with a comprehensive toolbox

Leapsome helps HR teams give managers everything they need to be effective, from engagement surveys to structured 1:1 templates, in a single user-friendly dashboard.

👉 Request a demo

‍

FAQ

How can I calculate the effectiveness of my managerial team?

There’s no universal formula to calculate manager effectiveness. However, tracking manager-specific promotion rates, high-performer turnover rates, and 360-degree feedback scores can give you a well-rounded picture of each manager’s ability to create an environment where employees thrive.

What are the development areas for managers?

Some of the most impactful skills and tools managers can learn to improve their effectiveness include:

• Communication and feedback skills
• Self-awareness
• Talent development
• Psychological safety
• Delegation and monitoring